Investing in the Age of AI
Climate, EU Taxonomy, Regulatory ComplianceArticles

The Fossil Gas Debate Turns to the Courts: Alignment under the EU Taxonomy

Published: April 19, 2023
Modified: April 19, 2023
Key Takeaways

The Step Towards Banning EU labelling of fossil gas as ‘sustainable’ in the EU Taxonomy.

In January of this year, fossil gas electricity generation was included in the EU Taxonomy as one of many activities that could potentially be considered green if they met certain technical criteria. As we anticipated, utility companies are facing significant challenges to demonstrate alignment, given the regulation’s stringent technical criteria.

Indeed, large European utilities with fossil gas operations, including Endesa, Fortum Oyj, and Verbund (p.160), have been unable to demonstrate alignment with the Taxonomy criteria in their 2022 annual reports.

This development is noteworthy as four NGOs are taking legal action against the European Commission to stop it from labeling fossil gas as ‘sustainable’ under the EU Taxonomy.

While we understand the perspective of the NGOs and would encourage a sustainability framework that considers all views, the reality is that the inclusion of fossil gas will have minimal impact on capital allocation decisions or investment portfolios, which is the main objective of the EU Taxonomy.

To explore previous insights on fossil gas regulations, read our latest article, “EU Taxonomy: How to Report on Fossil Gas-Related Activities.”

Research and Insights

Latest news and articles

Climate

Top-down, bottom-up, disclosure: building a physical climate risk view that holds up

Climate risk management is becoming a fiduciary duty. In 2020, the Australian pension fund REST settled a landmark case with member Mark McVeigh, committing to new disclosure processes and acknowledging that climate change is a material financial risk to its investments. But disclosure alone is no longer enough. Clients are paying attention to what the…

Climate

Data-Center Power Has Quadrupled. Big Tech’s Reported Scope 2 Has Done the Opposite

Data center power demand has quadrupled due to the artificial intelligence boom, but Big Tech’s reported carbon footprints are doing the opposite. Global carbon accounting rules are at the core of this inconsistency: under current greenhouse gas global (GHG) reporting standards, companies can report their electricity-related emissions (i.e., scope 2) using different accounting rules: Companies…

Market Insights

Geopolitical Risk and Portfolio Decisions: How Investors Are Adapting Policies, Exclusions, and Oversight

Geopolitical risk is currently reshaping how investors think about exclusions, investment policy, and portfolio oversight. At the same time, it is rewriting the macroeconomic playbook that long-term capital owners have relied on for decades. Trade fragmentation, shifting alliances, and a more interventionist policy environment are forcing investors to reconcile top-down macro views with bottom-up portfolio…